If you’re planning a new cedar fence in Franklin, TN, you’ll probably ask the big question: cedar vs pressure-treated, which option is better for your home?
At first glance, they can look similar, but the differences in appearance, durability, cost, and upkeep can make one a much better fit for your home than the other.
In Middle Tennessee, where the weather swings from humid summers to rainy winters, this choice matters even more.
The right fence won’t just protect your property; it can boost curb appeal, add privacy, and even increase your home’s value.
Let’s break down the pros and cons of each material so you can choose the best option for your Franklin property.
Cedar vs Pressure-Treated Fences: The Basics
Before diving into the comparison, it helps to understand what sets these two materials apart at the core.
Cedar Fences
Cedar is a naturally durable wood known for its warm, reddish tones and pleasant aroma. It contains natural oils that make it resistant to rot and insects, which means it performs well even without chemical treatment.
For Franklin homeowners, cedar is often considered the premium, design-forward choice that pairs beautifully with upscale neighborhoods like Belle Meade and Westhaven.
Pressure-Treated Wood Fences
Pressure-treated wood, usually pine, is chemically infused to withstand moisture, rot, and pests.
It’s more affordable than cedar and widely available, making it a practical option for long property lines or large backyards.
While it doesn’t have cedar’s natural beauty, staining can enhance its look and extend its lifespan.
In short, Cedar gives you luxury and longevity with minimal chemicals, while pressure-treated wood offers affordability and strength for everyday use.
A good example is our wood fence with brick columns case study, where we used pressure-treated southern pine for strength and paired it with brick for a timeless, high-end design.
Comparison of Pressure-Treated vs Cedar Fence in Franklin, TN
Choosing between cedar vs pressure-treated fences in Franklin isn’t only about the price tag; it’s about how the fence will look, how long it will last in Tennessee weather, and what kind of upkeep you’re willing to commit to.
To help you decide, we’ve broken the comparison into the most important factors for Franklin homeowners.
| Category | What You’ll Learn |
| Appearance and Curb Appeal | How each wood type affects the look and feel of your property. |
| Durability and Maintenance | Which material holds up better in Middle Tennessee’s climate. |
| Cost and Long-Term Value | Upfront pricing vs. return on investment. |
| Safety and Sustainability | Family-friendly and eco-conscious considerations. |
| Best Fit for Franklin Homes | Which option makes sense depending on your lifestyle and location. |
1. Appearance and Curb Appeal in Franklin
When it comes to first impressions, cedar usually wins the beauty contest. Its reddish tones look warm and timeless, and as it ages, it takes on a silvery-gray patina that still feels upscale.
In neighborhoods like Belle Meade or Brentwood, cedar fences often complement the architectural style of high-end homes and add to the overall curb appeal.
Pressure-treated wood, by comparison, starts with a greenish tint from the treatment process.
Over time, it fades into a muted brown or gray. Staining can certainly improve its look, but it doesn’t have the same natural elegance as cedar.
That said, for larger properties in Franklin or Thompson’s Station, where function and coverage matter more than making a design statement, pressure-treated wood offers a clean, sturdy backdrop at a lower cost.
Key Takeaway: Cedar is seen as the premium, design-forward choice in Franklin, while pressure-treated delivers a clean, functional look without the luxury price tag.
2. Durability and Maintenance in Tennessee Weather
Franklin’s climate is not gentle on fences. Between summer humidity, heavy rain, and freeze-thaw cycles, your fence needs to stand strong through every season.
A cedar fence in Franklin, TN, performs well naturally thanks to the oils in the wood that resist insects and decay. It can last decades if properly cared for.
To maintain its color, most homeowners apply stains every few years. If you skip the stain, cedar will still hold up, but it will fade into that classic weathered look.
Pressure-treated pine is designed to resist moisture and pests, making it a dependable choice where soil stays damp or drainage isn’t perfect.
The trade-off is that Tennessee’s summer heat can cause warping or cracking over time.
Keeping up with sealing and occasional repairs helps extend its lifespan, but it does require a little more ongoing attention than cedar.
Key Takeaway: A cedar fence in Franklin, TN, can weather local humidity with less upkeep, while pressure-treated suits damp or rocky soils but needs more maintenance.
3. Cost Today vs. Value Tomorrow
Budget is often the deciding factor. Pressure-treated wood is typically the more affordable choice upfront, which makes it appealing for homeowners who need to fence larger lots or long property lines.
Cedar, on the other hand, comes with a higher price tag initially, but many Franklin homeowners see it as a long-term investment.
Not only can it outlast pressure-treated wood with proper care, but it also boosts curb appeal and resale value.
In design-conscious areas like Westhaven, cedar fences are often viewed as a feature that adds character and sets a property apart.
Key Takeaway: Cedar often adds long-term value in Franklin’s housing market, while pressure-treated keeps upfront costs low for bigger properties.
4. The Eco-Friendly Choice: Cedar Fence in Franklin, TN
A pressure-treated privacy fence with lattice detail, offering both seclusion and style for a Franklin backyard.
For families who spend a lot of time outdoors, safety and sustainability can also influence the decision.
Cedar is chemical-free, naturally resistant, and considered one of the more eco-friendly wood choices. It’s also pet- and kid-safe, which gives many Franklin families peace of mind.
Pressure-treated wood today is much safer than in the past; the preservatives are tightly regulated, but it still involves chemical treatment.
If you’re eco-conscious or hosting kids and pets in the backyard, cedar may feel like the more natural option.
Key Takeaway: Cedar’s chemical-free makeup appeals to Franklin families and eco-conscious homeowners more than treated pine.
5. Which Fence Is Right for Your Franklin Home?
The decision isn’t black and white; it’s about what you value most in a fence, and the choice often comes down to your priorities.
Choose cedar if you value timeless curb appeal, lower long-term maintenance, and a design-forward look that enhances property value.
Choose pressure-treated wood if affordability and durability are at the top of your list, especially for larger properties where covering ground efficiently matters most.
Both materials can be excellent when installed correctly; it’s about matching the fence to your home, lifestyle, and budget.
Key Takeaway: Choose cedar for luxury curb appeal in Franklin neighborhoods, or pressure-treated for practical coverage at a lower cost.
Still deciding between cedar vs pressure-treated fence options? If you’re ready to move forward, check out our guide to installing wood fences in Nashville for a step-by-step look at the process.
Cedar or Pressure-treated? Let’s Build the Right Fence for Your Franklin, TN Home
Whether you lean toward the timeless beauty of a cedar fence in Franklin, TN, or the practicality of pressure-treated wood, your fence should reflect your lifestyle and enhance your property.
At Heron Building Co., we help Franklin and Nashville homeowners choose the right material, design, and installation approach to make their vision a reality.
Ready to start planning your fence? Let’s talk about your project today.
Comments +